LiVVaL

Linguaggio e Variazione | Variation in Language

Which of These Analyses Do You Prefer… among Those?

crossmark logo

Abstract
In a series of influential works, Cardinaletti and Giusti argue that true partitivity in Italian is expressed by the preposition di (of), whereas the prepositions tra/fra (among) introduce adjunct partitives. In this paper, we speculate on the ability of the wh-item quale (which) to qualify as a selector of true partitives, and attempt to account for the relativized minimality-mitigation effect associated with the so-called lexical restriction, observed in superiority configurations. Despite the intuitive appeal of a ‘selection’ analysis distinguishing true partitives from adjunct partitives, the results of our experiments indicate that a formulation of featural relativized minimality in terms of selection may not make the right predictions.


open access | peer reviewed

Submitted: Nov. 3, 2025 | Accepted: May 5, 2026 | Published Nov. 17, 2026 | Language: en

Keywords Adjunct-partitives • D-linking • Superiority effects • Partitives • wh-questions • Selection


read this chapter