LiVVaL

Linguaggio e Variazione | Variation in Language

Argumenthood and Syntactic Optionality

The Case of Instruments

crossmark logo

Abstract
Instruments are peculiar elements that blur the argument/adjunct distinction: they can be semantically obligatory or optional, yet are always syntactically optional. This study replicates Barbu’s (2020) cross-linguistic work in Italian to examine whether instruments are perceived as necessary participants at the semantic and syntactic levels, also depending on their semantic obligatoriness. The results confirm that perception varies with semantic obligatoriness and that instruments are often syntactically omitted, even when judged semantically necessary.


open access | peer reviewed

Submitted: Nov. 6, 2025 | Accepted: Feb. 5, 2026 | Published Nov. 17, 2026 | Language: en

Keywords Optionality • Instrumental role • Semantics • Syntax • Argumenthood • Psycholinguistics


read this chapter